Video Benchmarking and Information Site

  Home     MS Pro 7 Test/Results    MS Pro 6.0/6.5 Results
MS Pro 7 Review    Stagetools Moving Picture Review   FAQ
Firepod Review

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ulead MediaStudio Pro 7 Benchmark Page

Important Results:

Hyperthreading provides a 5% performance increase with Intel 875/865 systems (dual 400MHz memory) but only ~1.5% increase with Intel 845PE systems (333MHz memory).  Perhaps for Hyperthreading to have an impact additional bandwidth is required that the 875/865 systems have available.

An Intel 875/865 system with HT on is about 25% faster per clock than an Intel 845PE system with HT on.

An AMD dual channel nforce system with an Athlon XP cpu is about 12% more efficient at rendering than an Intel 875/865 P4 system.

Although MSP7 appears to not be heavily optimized for HT during rendering, the real time instant playback engine does seem to utilize HT quite well.  I noticed that the one scene that was not RT with HT off was RT with HT on with my system (P4 3.06).  In addition, all of the other clips I designated real time were even smoother with HT turned on.

Recommendations:

MediaStudio Pro 7 requires both a fast cpu AND fast fsb/memory.

Intel 875 systems paired with 800MHz fsb motherboards and dual PC3200 memory are excellent performers in MSP7.

Athlon XP's are also very good performers but are limited by clock speed.  At this point in time Intel has about a 30% lead in clockspeed over AMD, while AMD XP processors are only 12% more efficient at running the test.

It would be interesting to see how the Athlon 64 processors perform on the test as well as the new Prescott Intel P4 core.

HT gives a slight boost to rendering performance, but a much larger one to real time previews.

 

MS Pro 7.0 Results Sorted by Combined DV/MPEG-2 Encoding Time

MEDIASTUDIO Pro CPU Chipset/Memory Type CPU Speed DV   time Test Time (sec) fps MPEG2  time Test Time (sec) fps Total time  DV eff  MPEG eff Rank Non-RT Clips
Fred B. (7.01) P4 2.6C o/c 3.1 (HT on) Abit IS7 865PE - 948fsb - dual 474MHz memory 3081 7.21 441 10.7 7.47 467 10.1 15.08 289 306 100.0%  
Sciascia (7.01) P4 2.6C o/c 3.2 (HT on) Intel 875 - 784fsb- dual 392MHz memory 3200 7.44 464 10.1 8.01 481 9.8 15.45 316 327 97.6% 4C,5C, 6C
Fred B. (7.01) P4 2.6C (HT on) Abit IS7 865PE - fsb800 - dual 400MHz memory 2600 8.44 524 9.0 9.06 546 8.6 17.50 290 302 86.2%  
Sciascia (7.01) P4 2.6C (HT on) Intel 875 - 800fsb- dual 400MHz memory 2600 8.46 526 8.9 9.20 560 8.4 18.06 291 310 83.5% 4C, 6C
Piotr K. (7.01B1) Athlon XP 11.5x200 nForce2 - 400fsb - 400 MHz  RAM dual channel 2300 8.49 529 8.9 9.27 567 8.3 18.16 259 277 83.0%  
Sciascia (7.01) P4 2.6C (HT off) Intel 875 - 800fsb- dual 400MHz memory 2600 9.22 562 8.4 9.59 599 7.9 19.21 311 331 78.5% 4B,2C,4C,5C 6C
Mark D (7.01) P4 3.06   (HT on) Intel D845PE - 533fsb -333MHz memory 3060 9.58 598 7.9 10.12 612 7.7 20.10 389 398 75.0% All RT
Dave S. (7.01) Athlon XP 3000+ nForce2 - 333fsb - 333 MHz RAM dual channel 2167 10.07 607 7.7 10.43 643 7.3 20.50 280 296 73.6% All RT
Mark D (7.01) P4 3.06   (HT off) Intel D845PE - 533fsb -333MHz memory 3060 10.06 606 7.8 10.44 644 7.3 20.50 394 419 73.6% 5C
Giantman (7.01) Athlon XP 3000+ Asus A7N8X - fsb 400 -dual 333MHz memory 2167 10.09 609 7.7 10.49 649 7.2 20.58 281 299 73.3%  
Sciascia (7.01) P4 2.53 Intel 875 - 533fsb- dual 333MHz memory 2533 10.06 606 7.8 10.56 656 7.2 21.02 326 353 71.7% 2C,4C,5C 6C
Mark D (7.01B2) P4 2.4B (533fsb) Intel D845PE - 533fsb -333MHz memory 2400 12.16 736 6.4 12.51 771 6.1 25.07 376 393 60.2% 4B,TC,2C, 3C,4C,5C,6C
Boris B (7.01) Athlon XP 2500+ Sis 746 - 333fsb - 333Mhz memory 1833 12.27 747 6.3 13.00 780 6.0 25.27 291 304 59.7% 5A,2B,4B,6B, 2C,3C,4C,6C
Michael A. (7.0) P4 2.4B SIS 645DX - 533fsb - 333MHz memory 2400 12.32 752 6.3 13.44 824 5.7 26.16 384 420 57.6%  
Simon W. (7.0)